Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires

All-season tires are designed to perform year-round and specifically excel in dry, wet, and winter weather conditions. Indeed they are the most common ones used on the road today. Pirelli and Toyo are two names that excel in delivering great tires, especially in the all-season category.

They are both known for their innovative approach to ensuring that all the customers' needs are met and exceeded. The same is visible in their tire range of the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus and the Toyo Extensa A/S II. Both of these tires are meant for use on passengers. While both tires offer great performance, one has to be better than the other, right? Let’s compare Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires using SimpleScore to show where each tire excels and which one might be right for you.

Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus tires

All-season tires provide consistent traction and perform in dry, wet, and light winter weather conditions, which makes them an excellent choice for most of the passenger's vehicles. The P4 Persist AS Plus from Pirelli is designed to deliver efficient fuel economy and low rolling resistance with a longer tread life. Pirelli backs it with an exceptional 85,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.

With excellent features like wide circumferential grooves, angled lateral grooves, continuous central rib, and reinforced shoulders this tire boasts a SimpleScore of 9.4 out of 10 thanks to its handling, longevity, and traction.

Toyo Extensa A/S II tires

If you are looking for an alternate tire brand that is equally efficient in gripping the roads and delivering great performance all year round, look at the Toyo Extensa A/S II, which is an all-season tire that's designed for use on CUVs, SUVs, minivans, passenger cars, and light trucks, and offers drivers better wet and dry traction, increased fuel efficiency, good braking performance, and an up to 75,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty for T and H rated sizes, and 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty for V rated size. You also get Toyo's 500-Mile or 45-Day Trial, and Mileage Warranty (restrictions and limitations apply)

The Extensa A/S II includes an innovative design that gives drivers a quiet, comfortable ride, plus an optimized footprint that allows for even wear to extend the tire's tread life. This tire boasts a solid SimpleScore of 8.7.

Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires on traction

Traction is a critical aspect of tire performance, particularly in all-season tires. These tires are designed to provide grip across various weather conditions. These tires aim to strike a balance between performance in dry, wet, and light snowy conditions.

Comparing the above two based on traction, you will see that the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus is designed with symmetrical tread along with wide grooves that funnel water out of the tread to reduce the risk of hydroplaning on wet roads, and the P4 Persist AS Plus features dense siping that bites into the road for extra grip year-round. This has helped this tire to reach an average traction SimpleScore of 9.6 which is exceptionally great when it comes to performance.

The Toyo Extensa A/S II, on the other hand, has a score of 8.6 out of 10 in traction. This is thanks to a special symmetrical tread design that enhances grip and four wide grooves within its tread that remove water for added hydroplaning resistance. You get considerate traction with this tire and can depend on it for your all-season great traction performance.

When it comes to winter weather traction, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus has a solid edge over the Toyo Extensa A/S II.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus

Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires on handling

All-season tires are designed to provide a balance of performance for a variety of weather conditions, including dry, wet, and light snow. The handling of a tire is improved by different elements of the tire’s tread pattern, in addition to the tire’s overall design. The Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus sports an excellent 8.8 SimpleScore for handling, which is largely driven by the tire’s core rib that runs continuously, allowing it to be more durable and improving its handling.

On the flip side, the Toyo Extensa A/S II comes with a SimpleScore of 8.6. Featuring an innovative design that gives drivers a quiet, comfortable ride, plus an optimized footprint that allows for even wear to extend the tire's tread life.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus

Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires on longevity

The longevity aspect is equally important to traction and handling when purchasing a tire. The longevity of a tire depends on several factors, including the quality of the tire, driving habits, road conditions, and maintenance. Based on SimpleScore, this was the biggest gap between the two tires.

Starting with the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus, the tire offers an exceptional SimpleScore of 9.9 out of 10 on the longevity front. The tire’s tough, rugged rubber compound and reinforced construction work together to increase handling which allows for a longer tread life. Outside of that, the tire’s optimized design and tied shoulders put more rubber on the road which prevents irregular wear by evenly distributing road forces (in addition to boosting handling).

Conversely, the Extensa A/S II’s excellent 9.2 SimpleScore in longevity shows that it lags behind a little bit but still excels from many competitors. The Toyo Extensa A/S II also features reinforced construction, and its innovative tread design gives drivers a quiet, comfortable ride, plus even wear to extend the tire's tread life.

Here again, you will notice progress in terms of longevity for the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus over the Toyo Extensa A/S II.

Although both the tires perform solid when it comes to longevity, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus has an added advantage over the Toyo Extensa A/S II as the P4 Persist AS Plus comes with 85,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty against the 70,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty from the Toyo Extensa A/S II. Having said that Toyo also offers 500-Mile or 45-Day Trial, and a Mileage Warranty (restrictions and limitations apply)

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus

When to use each

While all-season tires offer convenience and versatility, they tend to have a longer lifespan compared to tires designed specifically for certain weather conditions, such as winter or summer tires. This is because they are constructed with a tread compound that balances handling and performance across different seasons.

Both the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus and Toyo Extensa A/S II may not provide optimal performance in extreme winter weather conditions. For example, in areas with heavy snowfall, dedicated winter tires might be necessary for improved traction and safety. That said, all-season tires are an excellent choice if you live in an area that only gets light snow.

Additionally, cautious driving habits and avoiding harsh conditions can help preserve the tread and overall integrity of the tires.

Which one should you choose?

So, which all-season tire is the right option for you? When looking at SimpleScore, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus comes out slightly ahead of the Toyo Extensa A/S II with an overall score of 9.4 versus 8.7. As noted above, there are key differences between the two tires and these need to be weighed against each other to determine what’s best for you. Finally (and maybe, most importantly), pricing on these two tires is a bit different as Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus tires cost at least $98.96 per tire while Toyo Extensa A/S II tires cost at least $80.43 per tire. That means a set of four Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus all-season tires will cost you at least $395.84 for a set of four, while a set of four Toyo Extensa A/S II tires will cost you at least $321.72.

Based on SimpleScore, you should choose the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus if you:

• Drive a passenger vehicle like the Audi A3 or the Chevrolet Malibu
• Want much better traction (9.6 vs 8.6)
• Prefer better longevity (9.9 vs 9.2) and mileage warranty (85,000 vs 75,000)
• Looking for solid handling (8.8 vs 8.6)
• Want the more affordable tire that’s also the better performer

Conversely, you should choose the Toyo Extensa A/S II if you:

• Drive a Honda Civic, Nissan Cube or a Fiat 500
• Are willing to pay a little bit more money for a tire that delivers great performance

Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires might not seem a close comparison on the surface, but the above clearly shows that either is a great option. Remember, both of the tire brands are some of the best tire manufacturers on the market, and that tradition continues with the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus and Toyo Extensa A/S II. At the end of the day, the decision to buy one or the other depends on your vehicle, where (and how) you drive, and what you care more about in terms of traction, handling, longevity, and price.

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.